Wednesday, 27 September 2023

Trial by Media (or Branding Russell III)

To start off, a comment from yesterday on my Brand piece:

"Oh dear you lost my interest as soon as you mentioned Brexit, which by default whatever else you illuded to was to be rhetoric of a kind I do not submit to! You have already in your piece arrived at a conclusion, and ignored any evidence to the contrary, as it does not ally to your political convictions! A sad state to publicly convict someone on social media,prior to any trial as if you are Judge, Jury etc. I look forward to your apology when all accusations are proven inaccurate, as will I if proven wrong!!"

This is a classic piece of ignoring the evidence. Had the writer, who was anonymous, bothered to read the piece, he (or she) would have discovered that I reached no such conclusion on Brand's guilt. He (or she) arrived at a conclusion totally ignorant, by their own admission, of what I wrote. Also they have tried Band and found him innocent, without access to the detailed evidence, which none of us have, beyond what has been reported thus far.

I guess he (or she) can be excused from reading the full piece by the way I referred, quite justifiably, to Brexiteers (I was quite scathing), but not from inferring from a position of ignorance.


The comment does, however, bear out my suggested link between Brexiteer and Brand acolyte. I don't imagine for one minute that the Venn diagram is a perfect circle, but I would suggest that the vast majority of Brand supporters sit in the Brexit circle - not the other way round.

However, to the subject, trial by media. What is meant by that? I do not believe that factual reporting is trial by media. If you did believe that, and that a fair trial would be jeopardised, yesterday's news item about the Bulgarian spy ring could be considered trial by media, indeed any factual reporting that is likely to result in a trial would be 'trial by media'. It's strange that the phrase is used only when someone who has a large following is under scrutiny - for others, they couldn't care less.

Nothing the Times, the Sunday Times and Channel 4 have produced make a conclusion - they merely present the results of an investigation, and investigations by the press and TV have exposed many areas of wrongdoing in the past, from Watergate to Savile. Do they go wrong? Certainly, but very infrequently.

What is trial by media is the manner in which Harry and Meghan have been treated by certain tabloids - supposition, twisting of words (and, in some cases outright lies) portrayed as fact and turned into character assassination. This is the stock in trade of tabloid journalism.

You don't have to be a genius to gather that the loudest voices calling the reporting on Brand 'trial by media' are Brand's supporters on his various channels, which is only natural. However, Brand himself engages in trial by media on his channels - making many allegations lacking any evidence (aka conspiracy theories).

If there's a trial by anything, it's trial by social media, although I have not seen many posts that outright condemn him as guilty. Plenty maintain his innocence. The jury's not even in position, let alone out.

Brand was out of control in a number of areas, but he was TV gold, so any concerns were conveniently ignored on hiring him in the first place, and extending his contract in the second. People, meaning those who loved his shows, demonstrate that this is a societal problem. He summed it up himself when he said (and I paraphrase when he said on the Despatches programme; "It's OK to be a bit of a nutter, as long as you're making someone some money."


Tuesday, 26 September 2023

Branding Russell II

I wrote on this subject less than a week ago, but reading comments on social media has crystalized my thoughts, especially arguing the toss with people who obviously believe Brand to be The Messiah (he's not the Messiah, he's just a very naughty boy) and are Brexiteers to boot, thus demonstrating the limits of their research skills; namely taking an emotional position and then furiously seeking out confirmatory information and ignoring anything contrary, especially if from experts. Some of the following is repetition, but most is new.


Let's look at this dispassionately, rather than emotionally, and I'm more than willing to be shot down in flames.

So, the police are now investigating claims.

As I have said before, the presumption of innocence is a legal device that puts the onus on the prosecution to prove a case. It does not apply outside of a court. Savile was never prosecuted - so was he innocent? 

What protects the accused is the libel laws. Brand has every right to sue those who say he is guilty before a trial for defamation, if he so chooses. 

As for publicity prejudicing a trial, yes, that is possible, if the publicity organ declares Brand guilty; however, it is individuals on social media who are possibly suggesting his guilt (or his innocence). Even then, any appeal following a jury trial is heard before a judge, not a jury, and a judge will disregard any publicity. Many are saying the case is subjudice, but subjudice literally means subject to a judicial decision - not before a case has come to trial.

Why have the accusers taken so long to go public? Firstly, very few possible victims of abuse have the wherewithal to take someone with a £16m bank account to court, or to face a defamation action if the accused is among the over 98% that are found not guilty through the difficulty in getting evidence; they would be bankrupted first by a long and costly action, so they keep quiet, sometimes for decades. Media organisations, however, do have deep enough pockets to take on the wealthy and collate disparate cases on the basis of widely circulating rumours. They can also compound the under 2% conviction rate by aggregating cases - 4 people, each with a 2% chance of winning, have a much greater chance than a single person acting on their own.

Secondly, rape is very difficult to prove - it can be one person's word against another. This is where investigative journalism comes in - showing a pattern of behaviour over time, which can be very persuasive in a court - rapists tend to repeat offend (between 2 and 6 times, according to the literature) and, due to the evidential problem, it's almost the perfect crime. Investigating journalism can also persuade others to come forward, as seems to be the case now.

Thirdly, many rape victims keep quiet for years out of pure, unadulterated embarrassment, fear or trauma. Also they know their lives will be ripped to pieces by the defence to find a single weakness in their character, even if totally unrelated

The media has reported that multiple accusations have been made (fact - at least one incident corroborated by medical records - but it's for a court to decide if the accusations are true, although a pattern of behaviour is alleged); that Brand has issued a rebuttal (fact) and have gone over his previous, colourful (factual) behaviour with clips. That's not trial by media - it's factual reporting, and they have teams of lawyers to ensure they don't stray into libel. If they do, Brand can sue for defamation. He's being treated no different to film producers, footballers, actors or other high-profile people accused of the same activity. The only difference is that Brand has a huge, devoted following who are extremely supportive and treat his as a Messiah. 

Remember, Daniel Khalife has pleaded not guilty of escaping from Wandsworth, despite this ignoring observed reality - the guilty also have a habit of shouting their innocence. Luis Rubiales insisted his kiss of Jenni Hermoso was consensual, despite never having asked her permission. Overbearing men see everything they do as consensual - it's the nature of the beast. Remember how Trump boasted of grabbing women's crotches (and his acolytes ignore that). A denial is not proof of innocence, except in the eyes of the devotee. Similarly, allegations are not proof of guilt until a trial. 

As for TV and radio channels continuing to employ him, despite the numerous rumours, you can't sack people on rumour without opening yourself up to libel. They're in a difficult position. 

Brand's disciples maintain he's so important that the media machine is ganging up on him because he's a threat. He's actually irrelevant and nothing more than a mouth on a stick, repeating what much more relevant people have been saying for years. The vast majority treat him as a clever crank who knows how to monetise the disaffected and conspiracy theorists. A good gig, if you can get it, and you can't blame him for that - there are many politicians and religious leaders who do precisely this.


Monday, 25 September 2023

Slavery in Beer

Last weekend we spent a long weekend in Branscombe, Beer and Lyme Regis, visiting the Beer Quarry, which has been worked since Roman times.

There's hardly a cathedral in England which doesn't have Beer stone in it somewhere.

The quarry workers were treated like slave labour and even had to buy their candles from the quarry owner. If a block they were hewing out of the seam was flawed in any way, they didn't get paid for it and were out of pocket. 

The expression 'not worth a candle' comes from stone quarrying underground - if a block was condemned, it wasn't worth the candle that was bought to cut it out of the seam. Also the expression 'it rings true' from the knocking of freshly hewn blocks with a hammer to test it, a ringing sound indicating it wasn't flawed and a dull sound suggesting a flaw.

I guess the expression 'you can't hold a candle to it' comes from the explosives industry.....

Masons got paid more than quarrymen and didn't have to buy their own candles. You might think it strange that sculpting the stone took place underground, but it did, as the stone remained soft in the cool temperatures and didn't dry out, making it much easier to carve. Limestone cures in daylight.

A quarryman's working life was between 10 and 12 years, after which he was either knackered from the backbreaking labour and limestone dust in his lungs, or dead. Yes, they could move elsewhere, but only to be exploited by the next rapacious capitalist who attended church every Sunday, like the family that owned the Penrhyn slate quarry near Bangor in North Wales.

When you look at a beautiful cathedral, think of the exploitation that took place to obtain the stone, with the church being party to it. When you're told slavery was abolished in the 1830s, give a thought to the poor in England, who were treated abysmally by the free market with no protections whatsoever. Thank God the Labour Party was started up to stop this exploitation.


Sunday, 24 September 2023

Signs of Ageing

All these adverts selling preparations and cosmetics that allegedly combat the key signs of ageing have yet to come up with something that prevents you forgetting where you put things, which it one of the most important key signs of ageing.



Saturday, 23 September 2023

Table Mod

Now I have the ash slab table finsihed, I want to add a modification to the LED light setup.


It's fiddly trying to switch the lights on with the switch being in a recessed chamber under the table, so I thought about adding an Arduino controller and Bluetooth switch so I could control it form a phone App.

Not being an electronics kind of person, I fear that the controller would take too much of the 9V battery's current, 7 x 24. There are 9 LEDs already and they drain the 9V battery within 12 hours when on.

Any electronics experts out there who can shed some light (forgive the unintended pun) on it?

I also got rid of the hideous, cartwheel candelabra over the table that everyone kept knocking their heads on, replacing it with the art deco lights I bought 2nd hand about 6 months ago. A vast improvement.



More in keeping with the decor. The 4 x 6W energy saving bulbs may be a bit bright, but I can play around with different wattages. 

I bought two of these ceiling lights, so I put the other one over the coffee table at the other end of the room to provide balance. There's no wire in the ceiling there to have it lit and it's mainly for effect. However, the bulb holders are just the right size to take tea-lights that provide a cosy glow.




The coffee table is actually an extending dining table that I adapted by shortening its legs. We never pull out the other leaf of the coffee table, so its length is stable. Perhaps my next project could be an ash slab coffee table to match the dining table.


Friday, 22 September 2023

Maps of Meaning

Jordan Peterson is a damned good psychologist with many papers behind him; however, his academic output has waned considerably. 

He stopped his clinical practice in 2016 and retired from teaching in 2017, preferring to immerse himself in the Culture War, which has somewhat tarnished his reputation, but is probably earning him a fortune off the back of his public intellectual platform.


That's not to say everything he says is rubbish, but there's a fair dusting of Culture War stuff, which labels him as far right in the eyes of his critics, which he says he's definitely not. He's certainly not daft.

He is, however, siding with the conspiracy theorists on the Climate Change issue. One of his posts last week highlighted a NASA report that says the earth is greening due to the increased CO2 in the atmosphere. However, it was a selective reading that missed out the bit about CO2 being a major contributor to GW and extreme weather events. 

Also, while CO2 is indeed a contributor to plant growth, it also results in a decrease in the nutritional value of plants and cereal crops due to the lower nitrogen intake.

In 1999, Peterson authored a book called Maps of Meaning, which concerns itself with how people construct meaning from beliefs. On the basis of that, I can't help but think that his Twitter account is actually a vast experiment where he's using comments on his Twitter feed as a laboratory and there will be a follow-up book to Maps of Meaning.


Thursday, 21 September 2023

Cost of Net Zero

Climate science deniers, under the influence of the oil lobby, are bemoaning the £1.3tn cost of net zero, maintaining this will bankrupt the country.

This is a very selective reading of the OBR report. The figure is purely the investment cost and does not take into account the operational savings of £991bn. A more accurate depiction is shown in the chart below.


From 2040 onwards, net operating savings are projected to outweigh the investment costs.

In addition, this cost is spread over many years and will be a percentage of GDP. The percentage of GDP, taking into account the savings, is less than 1% per annum. Put that way, it's not such an enormous amount.

They also miss out one very important figure - the cost of doing nothing - which is over 200% of GDP.

If you're going to quote from a report, quote all the report, not just cherry-picked figures that misrepresent it.

The MP for the 19th Century was on our local SW TV last night going on about the ban on ICE vehicles in 2030 impacting poor families disproportionately. For a start, the idea that he has compassion for poor families is utterly bizarre. Secondly, there will still be 2nd hand ICE vehicles for them to buy, as well as cheap, 2nd hand EVs by then. He's talking his usual nonsense and it's surprising the interviewer didn't hold his feet to the coals over his ridiculous assertion. Sunak obviously sees an opportunity to turn an utter rout at the GE into a common or garden rout, possibly saving a handful seats by pulling the wool over they eyes of those who would never think to look at a report.

Any policy that gains the support of Rees-Mogg and Truss must be looked into carefully. Also one that garners the support of the Sun, Mail, Express and Telegraph.

Can you blame Sunak? Yes, if it involves deceit by a parliamentarian, which is unfortunately all too common these days.


Wednesday, 20 September 2023

Branding Russell

I suppose the lesson for Russell Brand is to not be a twat in the first place and not to advertise the fact you're sexually incontinent.

The newspaper which launched this story is not a gossip rag; The Times is the paper of record and has an enviable record at that. There will be a team of lawyers on its payroll, and that of C4, telling them exactly what thet can and cannot say, based on the evidence that has been unearthed.


Many are castigating what they call a trial by media, but I wonder whether they were as vocal when the Weinstein story was reported in the US press and led to a court case. What the media has done is merely unearth evidence, which can be tested and contested in court.

Others are maintaining that Brand is innocent until proven guilty, unaware that the presumption of innocence is a legal device that applies only within a court of law and puts the onus on the prosecution to prove a case. It does not prevent Joe Public having an opinion, or voicing that opinion. What stops that is the law of libel, if the defendant is indeed found innocent by a court of law. The presumption of innocence did not apply to Jimmy Savile as he was never brought to court, but it can hardly be claimed he was innocent.

Brand too has recourse to the law to defend his reputation. However, when the Times and Channel 4 declare his guilt, that is 100%; when Brand declares his innocence, that is only 50%, because while the innocent will maintain they are innocent, the guilty also invariably maintain their innocence, thereby diluting the odds. The odds are therefore stacked against Brand in the court of public opinion.

As for the media launching an investigation, the publicity generated may persuade other victims to come forward on realising they're not on their own. It could, however, also bring forward cranks.

Unfortunately for Brand, his persona and previous actions make it easier for the public to believe he's guilty than innocent, and that's the fault of no-one but Brand.

His mum, Jo Brand, must be furious....


Tuesday, 19 September 2023

The High Street

Why are people so keen to revitalise our high streets?


Shops are a recent innovation and, in these days of on-line buying, is a business model that's doomed to a long, slow decline. Before permanent shops, people bought and sold things at the weekly market, or from a stall outside their houses.

Revitalising the high street is like trying to revitalise horse riding in the face of the motorcar, or encyclopedias in the face of Wikipedia (or a Triumph GT6 in the face of a Tesla....).

Even shops with high footfall suffer from them becoming nothing more than a shop window for people who then go home and try to find the same product at a lower price direct from the manufacturer or a small-scale wholesaler who doesn't have the high overheads of a shop. We say one thing and do another - a bit like ideology in politics.

Yes, there will always be a market for bricks and mortar shops in respect of some products, but they are few and far between. Totnes High Street is more like shopping districts should be - a collection (and indeed a collective) of independent retailers who provide unique products that can't be provided anywhere else. So many high streets are facsimiles of others and it's hard to know where you are. They're not individual; they're bland in the extreme.

I appreciate that most shops are unsuitable for conversion into housing, but many are and, if we have a shortage of houses, then turning them into housing would solve a pressing problem. On August 1st, 2021, the new permitted planning development rights (PDR) came into force. These new rules allow the conversion of any Class E building (shops) into a residential space (C3 'dwelling house') without the need for full planning permission if certain conditions are met.


Monday, 18 September 2023

Electric Car Chase

Could you imagine a car chase using electric cars?


How would The Italian Job or Bullit have fared at the box office if the cars had been silent?

You'd need the baddies to be in noisy ICE cars and the police in electric cars - the baddies wouldn't stand a chance against instant, full torque. That is unless they ran out of charge mid chase.

If both were in electric cars, then it would be up to the accompanying soundtrack to provide the excitement.