I was watching Antiques Roadshow when the expert introduced a painting by Alfred Wallis, a self-taught St Ives artist.
“He wasn't trained as an artist,” she explained.
“Well, that's not difficult to tell,” I remarked to the television.
What followed was a valuation of £20,000 for something that, to my eye, looked remarkably like a child's first attempt at painting a harbour. The perspective was all over the place, the proportions were absurd and the execution suggested that mastering a paintbrush had never been a particularly pressing ambition.
Apparently, this is called 'naïve art'. A splendid expression, which seems to confer artistic legitimacy upon what might otherwise be described as not being very good at drawing.
Now, before the art establishment reaches for its collective smelling salts, I should explain that I have nothing against Alfred Wallis. Quite the opposite. He was a former mariner who took up painting in his seventies, following the death of his wife. He painted ships and harbours from memory, often on scraps of cardboard, using whatever materials came to hand. There's something rather touching about that. An old sailor preserving his memories of a maritime world that was disappearing.
And I'm perfectly happy to believe that those paintings have historical interest, charm and even a certain expressive quality.
But £20,000?
The interesting part of the story isn't really Wallis. It's what happened when two established artists, Ben Nicholson and Christopher Wood, encountered his work in 1928. They were captivated by its simplicity, its disregard for conventional technique and its apparently instinctive approach to representation.
In other words, qualities that might have earned a less fortunate amateur painter a kindly suggestion to take up gardening suddenly became evidence of artistic genius.
And once influential people declared Wallis important, other influential people agreed. Museums collected his work. Art historians explained its significance. Collectors bought it. Prices rose. Each successive endorsement reinforced the last until an old sailor's paintings on discarded cardboard became valuable objects in an international art market.
There's a fascinating circularity to this. A painting is valuable because important people say it's important. We know those people were right because the painting is now valuable.
Try applying that logic to almost anything else.
Of course, defenders will argue that art isn't about technical competence. Picasso could paint conventionally before abandoning conventional representation. Artistic merit, they'll explain, lies in originality, emotional expression and the ability to make us see the world differently.
Fair enough. But there's an important distinction between an accomplished artist deliberately rejecting the rules and someone who never learnt them in the first place. That doesn't automatically invalidate the latter's work, but neither should technical inability be treated as a qualification in its own right.
And originality isn't quite the trump card it's sometimes assumed to be. Every child's drawing is original. Most are charming. Very few warrant a security guard.
What I find particularly revealing is that Wallis himself never enjoyed the financial rewards subsequently attached to his name. He died in poverty in 1942. The substantial sums now changing hands are rewards for ownership of his work, not for the man who produced it.
Perhaps people genuinely find profound beauty in these paintings. I wouldn't presume to tell them what they should enjoy. But enjoying something and believing it possesses an intrinsic financial value of £20,000 are very different propositions.
I suspect the latter depends overwhelmingly upon collective belief, sustained by institutional approval and the reassuring knowledge that somebody else might eventually pay even more.
Which makes me wonder what will happen in fifty years. Will future collectors still regard Wallis as a major figure in British art, or will changing tastes leave them wondering why their grandparents paid a small fortune for what looks like a child's scrawl?
I don't know. Art history has a habit of making fools of confident predictions.
But I do know that if Alfred Wallis had submitted the same painting to the local village art exhibition without his name attached, I very much doubt somebody would have offered £20,000 for it.
Perhaps that's the real masterpiece here. Not the painting, but the extraordinary human ability to create financial value simply by agreeing that it exists.
Wallis painted the picture. The art establishment painted the price tag.










