Monday, 16 October 2023

The 2 State Solution

More thoughts on the Israeli/Hamas debacle.

It is often said that the Palestinians and Jews (they weren't yet Israelis) had been offered a 2 state solution in 1937. The Jews accepted and the Palestinians refused, losing the chance of settling the problem. Opprobrium has been heaped on the Palestinians ever since. After all, why would they turn down such a brilliant solution?


However, Imagine a bunch of Frenchmen from Normandy had been busy migrating to England (or whatever country you belong to) for several decades, in ever increasing numbers, claiming suzerainty over England because it once belonged to Normandy a thousand years ago (you could use the Welsh as an example too, with a history going back even further in terms of ownership).

There are tensions between the native English and the interloper Norman French. The international community steps in and proposes a 2 state solution - the west of England is for the English and the east is for the Norman French (as an aside, it wasn't actually like that in 1066 and the Norman French decided to take the bloody lot in one, fell swoop).

I cannot, for the life of me, imagine that the English would accept such a 2 state solution and would tell the luminaries within the international community to piss off and do one, and rightly so. The EDL would probably see an unprecedented increase in membership too. So why the hell should the Palestinians have accepted exactly the same solution?

I can't help seeing an analogy between Israel and Palestine on the one hand, and the behaviour of the American government toward Native Americans in the 1700s and 1800s. Migrants from all over Europe descended on North America, appropriating ancient tribal lands and fomenting wars with the various native tribes. These tribes, due to the technological superiority of the European settlers, kept losing, were eventually soundly defeated and then herded into reservations. However, even the reservation lands were gradually eroded as more land was needed for settlers. The analogy is startlingly similar.

According to historical records and media reports, since its founding, the United States has systematically deprived native Americans of their rights to life and basic political, economic, and cultural rights through killings, displacements, and forced assimilation, in an attempt to physically and culturally eradicate this group. Even today, Native Americans still face a serious existential crisis.

Russia has annexed land belonging to Ukraine and they are fighting a war. Do we support Russia's annexation? 

What Israel has been engaged in, whether willingly or not, is indubitably the precise definition of colonialism - the policy or practice of acquiring full or partial political control over another country, occupying it with settlers, and exploiting it economically.

However, as I have said before, we are where we are. The only route is forwards and going over past transgressions does no-one any good. They must, however, be accepted if progress is to be made. There is currently too much grief on both sides of the conflict to extend compassion to the other side.

Is a 2 State Solution the only viable alternative? Well, from a pragmatic perspective, yes. The only other alternative is a 1 State Solution with that state being Israel occupying the whole area which, however, would promulgate continued warfare for decades, if not centuries, until the entire Palestinian population were to be eliminated.

I heard an Israeli commentator say that Netanyahu, in reference to his catastrophic intelligence and security failure, stored Israel's iron swords in seawater. It didn't help the situation back in March when the far right, ultra-nationalist, Israeli Finance Minister, Bezalel Smotrich, called for a Palestinian village to be 'erased'.

Hamas seeks to undermine Zionism in its totality - for Hamas, the mere fact of Israel's existence is the occupation. However, Israel isn't going away, so it's not a politically valid view and is an unreachable, idealistic perspective. 

Hamas' strategy is to portray Israel to other actors in the Middle East as ethically indistinguishable from them in terms the number of forthcoming deaths in Gaza, despite the vast difference in visceral reaction to close quarters, physical violence by Hamas on the one hand and the mere pressing of a button from Israeli territory that rains down death from afar (or cutting off essentials to civilians) on the other hand. The former is seen as unacceptable, while we tolerate the latter with greater ease due to its impersonal nature.

Israel's conduct in Gaza and the West Bank in the past has been recognised by various international organisations as entailing gross human rights violations and crimes against humanity - Israel is not blameless, especially under its current government. What Israel proposes to do in Gaza is enormously counterproductive and ensures it falls into Hamas' trap, which may alter the view of other actors in the Middle East with which Israel has been building bridges. Hamas will actively engage in false flag attacks on its own people, who they don't give a jot for, and blame them on Israel.

If Israel wants to assume the moral high ground and not lose international support, despite its record on human rights in Gaza, it must act with massive restraint in the face of insuperable provocation. That is unlikely with the current, belligerent government which is consumed by a desire for revenge. It's an age old ploy to stay in power.

Even if you believe the Palestinian people should suffer collective punishment for the actions of Hamas, then you have to take into account the fact Gaza has one of the youngest populations on earth and that fact could stimulate a massive recruitment drive which will plague Israel and Europe for decades to come. Hamas will want to take advantage of that.

Terrorist: a person who uses unlawful violence and intimidation, especially against civilians, in the pursuit of political aims. 

Fools nail their colours to a specific mast when, due to the existential nature of the war, ethics and morals necessarily go out of the window and both sides have engaged in the very definition of terrorism. It's merely a question of the distance from which the terrorism takes place. 

The conflict is increasingly becoming mired in theatrical and performative revenge.

I saw a Twitter (X) post last week that summed up the situation: "It is not Islamophobic to detest Hamas for the murder of Israelis. It is not anti-Semitic to detest Netanyahu’s Govt for its treatment of Palestinians. It is Islamophobic or anti-Semitic to attack Muslims or Jews for the actions of Hamas or Netanyahu’s Govt."



Sunday, 15 October 2023

Prince Philip's Wobble Box

We quite frequently stay at a caravan site in Broadway, in the middle of the Cotswolds. It's in the grounds of an old shunting yard with a rather nice building that's been converted into a bit of a museum of caravans.

There are two exhibits - one of the earliest, luxury caravans from the 1800s, and Prince Philip's personal caravan which he used when out on sporting events, such as competitive carriage riding. 

The following couple of photos are of the Wanderer, the world’s first purpose-built leisure touring caravan, commissioned by Dr William Gordon Stables and built in 1884/5. Dr Gordon Stables was a retired Royal Naval Surgeon who had gained some celebrity as an author of adventure stories for boys, which drew on his own experiences at sea. He was a prominent pioneer of leisure caravanning and the first Vice-President of the Caravan Club (later renamed Caravan and Motorhome Club). 

The first journey taken by Dr Gordon Stables was 1300 miles from his home in Twyford, Berkshire to Inverness in Scotland. The Doctor saw many parallels between a caravan and a boat, which is why The Wanderer is always fondly referred to as ‘she’ in the same way that a sea vessel would be. The Doctor would regularly take to the road, clad in his striking Highland dress with a variety of pets and sometimes one of his children in tow. He often penned his latest novel or an article on the journey.



Then we come to Prince Philip's wobble box, a seemingly normal, 1993 Fleetwood Garland. It was purchased second-hand in 1998 by Prince Philip. As the Caravan and Motorhome Club’s Patron since 1952, Prince Philip had regularly attended Club campsites and events, reportedly exploring members’ caravans enthusiastically and assessing them for their practicality. After taking up the sport of carriage driving in 1973, caravans offered a private space for The Duke and his team to prepare and relax during competitions.



Friday, 13 October 2023

A Chip Off the Old Block

 That's another full tipper truck of logs put into the log shed.



Altogether, we now have £800 worth of logs in the log shed (2 full tipper trucks), comprising 5 and a half, floor to rafters walls that extend 4 feet out from the back. That is far more than we'll use in one winter, but the price is rising all the time.


We've had the fire on twice thus far, not so much because of the cold, but to drive off the damp air. Next week it will be on for the cold.

Hopefully, by next year we'll be able to put the underfloor heating on again, if electricity prices drop to pre-crisis levels. If we have a particularly sunny winter, I'll be able to take advantage of the solar PV in order to put the air-source heat pump on during the day. The solar thermal will augment hot water on sunny days too.


Hypocrisy - the New Murder

Harry and Meghan are coming under fire from the right wing gutter press again (no surprise there). This time for using a fleet of '5 gas guzzling SUVs' at an event in New York. This labels them as eco-hypocrites. 


Now, hypocrisy is the new murder - no, it's worse than murder for right wing, oil lobby sycophants who look for any excuse to label those they don't like as hypocrites.

A simple Google search will reveal that Harry and Meghan use a company called TorchStone to provide them with security. TorchStone are the experts and have provided security for Presidents of the United States. 

Harry and Meghan don't live in New York, they live in California, so it's unlikely in the extreme they flew 5 of their own cars to New York. TorchStone will have arranged the necessary transport, selecting the best vehicles for the purpose, which would presumably have extra features not available in the average, off the shelf models from Rent-A-Car and therefore hired some from a company that specialises in close protection vehicles. 

It's highly unlikely that anyone has made a close protection EV. In fact, I can't find a single mention of one on Google. They're all huge SUVs with heavy, bulletproof armour which require large, V8 engines. 

Chevrolet SUVs seem to be the choice of US close protection personnel, whereas specialist Range Rovers are preferred in the UK. Strange they don't have a go at the Royal family for adopting exactly the same protection strategy.

If the papers that seem to specialise in negative stories about Harry and Meghan have a problem with their choice of vehicles when not at home, perhaps they need to have a word with the experts - TorchStone or the companies that convert cars into protection vehicles.

There again, we know what the right wing press thinks of experts. They supported their expert, Truss.


Thursday, 12 October 2023

Terrorist?

Some, especially on the right, are getting their knickers in a twist about the BBC not calling Hamas terrorists. They have a habit of this - the New IRA are not called terrorists, but dissident Republicans.

Let's analyse the term a bit more closely. A terrorist is defined as 'a person who uses unlawful violence and intimidation, especially against civilians, in the pursuit of political aims'.


There are many that argue Israel's current government has committed unlawful violence and intimidation against Palestinian civilians in pursuit of claiming their land. Even the cutting off of water, food and electricity is dicing with international law. Israel has bombed civilians in Lebanon and Syria too.

If the BBC has to call Hamas terrorists, which they undoubtedly are, then in the interest of impartiality, it arguably also has to call the Israeli government terrorists. The current difference between Hamas' terrorism and that of the Israeli government is purely a matter of distance from which the terrorism takes place.

The Palestinian people in Gaza have had no elections since 2006 - Hamas installed themselves for a 2nd term without elections. They are terrorising not only Israelis, but their own people, many of which just want to get on with their lives. Gazans are also suffering from the actions of the Israeli government - justifiably, in eyes of many, but they have no choice. They can't leave and they can't vote Hamas out. They're in the world's largest, open-air prison.

There's also the matter of people calling for those in the UK waving Palestinian flags in to be arrested. However, the Palestinian flag is not the flag of Hamas, but it is also the flag of the PLO on the West Bank (or what's left of it). The Palestinian flag is, however, banned in Israel in public places.

On the wider issue of Hamas' objective. Could it be possible that, because Israel is reaching peace deals with surrounding Islamic countries, they want to provoke an over-reaction in order to stop that process in its tracks?


Wednesday, 11 October 2023

Drone

 No.1 Son made the mistake of buying an SDJ Mini SE drone and leaving it at our house. I broke it by crashing it into a tree. I did, however, fix it.

Here are a couple of videos I took.


And here is a series of photos No.1 Son took - he's far more adventurous than me and will fly it at night. It is his, after all, so he can take the risks.











It has a range of 6-10km.

He had a go at videoing the Old Sodbury church, as well as the first GWR Sodbury Tunnel vent shaft, which is up on the escarpment and one of a series. The church is about half a mile away and the vent is probably just short of a mile. Both flights were controlled from our house.

And here he shows off a bit by flying it through our house:


Tuesday, 10 October 2023

Gaza / Israel

I used to work for an Israeli company, being their MD for Europe, and have visited Israel many times; however, I try not to allow that to cloud my opinions of the conflict, despite having made many friends there.


Some important points:

  1. Agreed and inviolable borders engender friendships (a version of high fences make good neighbours).
  2. Friendship itself can encourage porous borders (good neighbours have open doors).
  3. Imposed borders breed conflict (compulsory purchase orders cause strife).
  4. Religion knows no borders.
The cause of the current flare up goes back many decades and each side engages in tit-for-tat, with no end in sight. It's easy to nail one's colours to the mast for one side or the other, but each side has engaged in some pretty atrocious behaviour.


The above maps show how Israel has expanded by taking over Palestinian land. It could be said, however, that the land was needed to prevent strategically vulnerable corridors. There again, Israel was created by the West, without so much as a by your leave to the original inhabitants of the Ottoman Empire - imposed borders; indeed, an imposed country.

Collective guilt about historic antisemitism results in the West generally favouring Israel, plus the fact that Israel is one of the few functioning democracies in the Middle East. Democracy is worshipped in the West, despite it being increasingly under threat from populists. Hamas being sponsored by Iran is another factor in Israel's favour in the eyes of the West. There again, Hamas is viewed by many Palestinians much like the IRA was viewed by the Irish Catholics - one man's terrorist is another's freedom fighter.

Netanyahu seems to be getting it in the neck for the egregious lapse in security. It seems populists are shit at the every-day important stuff, as we and the Americans have learned - and many other countries that are lurching toward populism will discover.

Fully expect Russia to exploit the situation, especially as Putin obtains weapons from Iran, Hamas' key backer. But Putin has to be careful as there are over 900,000 Jews of Russian heritage in Israel, if not actually born there and part of the Aliyah of the 90s. A Middle East conflict that draws in the West and deflects from Ukraine would suit Putin perfectly. It would also benefit certain leaders in the West, as wars have a habit of ensuring re-election.


Monday, 9 October 2023

T3

My mate bought a 1991 VW T3 campervan. He's not sure whether he's going to keep it or flip it. However, he asked me to renovate it. It needed quite a bit of work, as you can see.











Two and a half days later, it was transformed. Took all the stickers off, cleaned the carpets, ground out the rot, Jenolited what was left, filled the holes, primed it, touched it up in spray paint and then buffed the new paint into the old.

There was one area that would have benefitted from welding, but it's near the petrol filler, so I wasn't going to do that in a hurry and survive. The rot was halted in its tracks though with the hole covered in filler.

Bugger of a job finding the right colour paint - took me 3 goes to get the correct shade, and even then it wasn't perfect. Couldn't find the paint code on the VIN plate, so had to go on intuition. Here's the result.

Believe it or not, some people replaced the air-cooled T3 engines with ones from early Porsche 911s, which were also air-cooled.


Sunday, 8 October 2023

Think Floyd

Went to see Think Floyd, a Pink Floyd tribute band, in Frome last night. They were very, very good.

Here is a video of a few selected excerpts.


Saturday, 7 October 2023

England Expects

 At what stage does someone become British, especially if there's immigration in your family history?


It may seem a simple question, but not when you think of it. Is it a question that I pondered when watching David Olugosa's latest TV programme about the union that we call the United kingdom, but refer to (mistakenly) as Britain.

I consider myself British, despite not having been born here. But can I lay claim to the 'we' when people say 'we' beat the French at Trafalgar? I can lay claim to 'we' beat Napoleon at Waterloo, as the Dutch formed part of Wellington's army.

My passport says British - despite not being able to lay claim to being English, Scottish, Welsh or Northern Irish. My kids can claim to be English, as England is their place of birth, but are they truly British in the way a certain section of people lay claim to Britishness? Does it take a certain number of generations of being born here?

Is it, perhaps, a claim to the cultural legacy, rather than 'blood and soil'?

One thing that came to light in Olugosa's programme was Nelson's famous signal at Trafalgar; England Expects that Every Man Will do His Duty. England expects, despite the fact a large proportion of his navy was not English, but Scottish, Welsh and Irish. The United Kingdom had already been established before Trafalgar, so was he a raving English nationalist?

What Olugosa misses, however, is that the signal book used was created in 1800 and didn't have a signal for United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland, or indeed Britain. The Acts of Union 1800 united the kingdoms of Great Britain and Ireland in 1801, forming the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland. However, before 1801 it was known for nearly 100 years as Great Britain. It would have had to be spelled out letter by letter, which would waste time.

I wonder if any Brexiteers watch Olugosa's programme? It charts the history of a number of separate nations which came together in a political Union that has lasted hundreds of years - a political Union they defend vociferously, while denigrating another Union that has yet to achieve full, political union. It's ironic that the United Kingdom's Union is under threat from the same forces of nationalism that led to Brexit.

It's also ironic that a number of Conservative Brexiteers are calling on Nigel Farage to rejoin the Tory Party and change it from within. A bit like staying in the EU in order to change it from within. We live in strange times when what's good for the goose is touted as not being good for the gander.